The Real Cost of Speeding Tickets: Insurance Rate Impact Analysis by State

​Discover exactly how much a speeding ticket will raise your insurance rates in your state. Our data-driven analysis reveals which companies penalize least, how long rate increases last, and proven strategies to protect your premium.

That $150 speeding ticket might seem manageable—until you realize it could cost you an additional $2,400 in insurance premiums over the next three years. At SpeedTicketBeaters.com, our 20+ years helping drivers fight tickets has given us unique insight into the true financial impact of speeding violations. This comprehensive analysis breaks down exactly how much your rates will increase by state, insurance company, and violation severity—and most importantly, how to prevent these increases entirely.

The Hidden Math: How Insurance Companies Calculate Ticket Penalties

Insurance companies don't randomly raise rates after a ticket. They follow specific internal algorithms:
The Surcharge FormulaMost major insurers use a percentage-based surcharge system:

• First minor speeding ticket (1-15 mph over): 20-30% increase
• Moderate speeding (16-25 mph over): 25-40% increase
• Excessive speeding (26+ mph over): 40-100% increase


The Multiplication Effect

These percentages apply to your entire premium, not just the liability portion. For example:

• $1,500 annual premium
• 25% surcharge for speeding
• Real impact: $375 additional per year
  
• Most insurers keep surcharges active for 3-5 years:
• Year 1: Full surcharge (e.g., 25%)
• Year 2: Full surcharge continues
• Year 3: Full or slightly reduced surcharge
• Years 4-5: Gradually reducing (depending on insurer)

State-by-State Insurance Impact Analysis 

California

• Average premium increase: 42% ($984 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3-4 years
• Total average cost: $3,444
• Worst insurance company: Mercury (+55%)
• Most forgiving company: Wawanesa (+31%)
• Points duration: 3 years on record

New York

• Average premium increase: 31% ($686 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3 years
• Total average cost: $2,058
• Worst insurance company: Allstate (+45%)
• Most forgiving company: State Farm (+22%)
• Points duration: 18 months on record

Texas

• Average premium increase: 35% ($723 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3 years
• Total average cost: $2,169
• Worst insurance company: Progressive (+47%)
• Most forgiving company: Texas Farm Bureau (+24%)
• Points duration: 3 years on record

Florida

• Average premium increase: 45% ($1,042 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3-5 years
• Total average cost: $4,168
• Worst insurance company: Geico (+59%)
• Most forgiving company: State Farm (+38%)
• Points duration: 5 years on record

Illinois

• Average premium increase: 28% ($592 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3 years
• Total average cost: $1,776
• Worst insurance company: American Family (+37%)
• Most forgiving company: State Farm (+19%)
• Points duration: 4-5 years on record

Pennsylvania

• Average premium increase: 33% ($689 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3 years
• Total average cost: $2,067
• Worst insurance company: Progressive (+41%)
• Most forgiving company: Erie Insurance (+24%)
• Points duration: 3 years on record

Ohio

• Average premium increase: 25% ($475 annually)
• Duration of impact: 2-3 years
• Total average cost: $1,188
• Worst insurance company: Liberty Mutual (+36%)
• Most forgiving company: Nationwide (+18%)
• Points duration: 2 years on record

Georgia

• Average premium increase: 38% ($823 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3 years
• Total average cost: $2,469
• Worst insurance company: Progressive (+49%)
• Most forgiving company: Country Financial (+28%)
• Points duration: 2 years on record

North Carolina

• Average premium increase: 42% ($879 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3 years
• Total average cost: $2,637
• Worst insurance company: Geico (+54%)
• Most forgiving company: NC Farm Bureau (+31%)
• Points duration: 3 years on record

Michigan

• Average premium increase: 56% ($1,425 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3-5 years
• Total average cost: $5,700
• Worst insurance company: Progressive (+68%)
• Most forgiving company: Auto-Owners (+43%)
• Points duration: 2 years on record

New Jersey

• Average premium increase: 47% ($1,082 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3 years
• Total average cost: $3,246
• Worst insurance company: Allstate (+59%)
• Most forgiving company: NJM (+36%)
• Points duration: 5 years on record

Virginia

• Average premium increase: 29% ($579 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3 years
• Total average cost: $1,737
• Worst insurance company: Geico (+39%)
• Most forgiving company: USAA (+21%)
• Points duration: 2 years on record

Washington

• Average premium increase: 31% ($621 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3 years
• Total average cost: $1,863
• Worst insurance company: Farmers (+43%)
• Most forgiving company: PEMCO (+22%)
• Points duration: 3 years on record

Massachusetts

• Average premium increase: 33% ($748 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3-5 years
• Total average cost: $2,992
• Worst insurance company: Safety Insurance (+43%)
• Most forgiving company: MAPFRE (+26%)
• Points duration: 6 years on record

Arizona

• Average premium increase: 36% ($781 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3 years
• Total average cost: $2,343
• Worst insurance company: American Family (+47%)
• Most forgiving company: USAA (+25%)
• Points duration: 3 years on record

Tennessee

• Average premium increase: 32% ($678 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3 years
• Total average cost: $2,034
• Worst insurance company: Farmers (+43%)
• Most forgiving company: Tennessee Farmers (+23%)
• Points duration: 2 years on record

Indiana

• Average premium increase: 26% ($492 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3 years
• Total average cost: $1,476
• Worst insurance company: Progressive (+38%)
• Most forgiving company: Indiana Farmers (+19%)
• Points duration: 2 years on record

Missouri

• Average premium increase: 29% ($574 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3 years
• Total average cost: $1,722
• Worst insurance company: American Family (+40%)
• Most forgiving company: State Farm (+21%)
• Points duration: 3 years on record

Maryland

• Average premium increase: 34% ($734 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3 years
• Total average cost: $2,202
• Worst insurance company: Allstate (+45%)
• Most forgiving company: Erie Insurance (+26%)
• Points duration: 2 years on record

Wisconsin

• Average premium increase: 24% ($459 annually)
• Duration of impact: 3 years
• Total average cost: $1,377
• Worst insurance company: American Family (+34%)
• Most forgiving company: West Bend Mutual (+18%)
• Points duration: 5 years on record

Insurance Company Comparison: Who Penalizes Most Severely?
Our analysis of rate increases across major insurers reveals significant differences:

Most Punitive Insurance Companies

1. Farmers: Average 44% increase
2. Progressive: Average 42% increase
3. Geico: Average 38% increase
4. Allstate: Average 37% increase
5. Liberty Mutual: Average 35% increase

Most Forgiving Insurance Companies

1. USAA: Average 21% increase
2. State Farm: Average 25% increase
3. American Family: Average 27% increase
4. Nationwide: Average 29% increase
5. Travelers: Average 31% increase

The Speed Factor: How MPH Over Affects Your Rates 
Not all speeding tickets impact insurance equally:

1-9 MPH Over

• Average increase: 20%
• Insurance point value: 0-2 points
• Company-specific policies: Some insurers ignore first minor offense

10-14 MPH Over

• Average increase: 25%
• Insurance point value: 2-3 points
• Company-specific policies: First ticket forgiveness sometimes applies

15-19 MPH Over

• Average increase: 32%
• Insurance point value: 3-4 points
• Company-specific policies: Almost always surcharged

20-29 MPH Over

• Average increase: 43%
• Insurance point value: 4-6 points
• Company-specific policies: High-risk category triggers

30+ MPH Over

• Average increase: 80%+
• Insurance point value: 6+ points
• Company-specific policies: Possible non-renewal

The Insurance Reporting Timeline

1. Ticket issued: Not yet reported to insurance
2. Payment/guilty plea: Reported to DMV within 30 days
3. DMV record update: 2-6 weeks after conviction
4. Insurance discovery: Next renewal or periodic check

A speeding ticket's true cost lies not in the fine you pay to the court but in years of inflated insurance premiums. By understanding exactly how these increases work and taking proactive steps to prevent them, you can save thousands of dollars over time.

Received a speeding ticket?

Contact us for a free consultation to protect your driving record and your premium!
​